It’s a dilemma many of us face – should we put any extra money towards paying off debt or should we invest it instead? On one hand, being debt-free can provide a huge sense of financial freedom and security. But on the other hand, investing can potentially lead to greater long-term wealth. As someone who has grappled with this decision myself, I know how challenging it can be to figure out the right path forward.

In this post, I’ll break down the key factors to consider when deciding whether to prioritize debt payoff or investing. I’ll share my own personal experiences, as well as insights from financial experts, to help you determine the best strategy for your unique financial situation. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of the pros and cons of each approach so you can make an informed decision about how to allocate your extra funds.

The Case for Paying Off Debt

One of the most compelling arguments for prioritizing debt payoff is the guaranteed “return” you’ll see. When you pay down a debt, especially one with a high interest rate, you’re essentially earning that interest rate as a return on your money. For example, if you have a credit card with a 20% APR, every dollar you put towards that balance is essentially earning you a 20% return.

This is a much higher guaranteed return than you’d likely get from most investment vehicles, especially in the current economic climate with low interest rates. Investing always carries some risk, whereas eliminating high-interest debt provides a surefire way to improve your financial standing.

Eliminating debt also frees up cash flow that can then be put towards other financial goals, like saving for emergencies, retirement, or a down payment on a home. I experienced this firsthand when I finally paid off my student loans a few years ago. The extra $300 per month I had previously been putting towards those loans allowed me to ramp up my retirement contributions and start saving for a house down payment.

Additionally, being debt-free can provide an immense sense of psychological and emotional relief. The weight of carrying large debts can be a major source of stress and anxiety. Lifting that burden can do wonders for your overall well-being and peace of mind. As someone who has been there, I can attest to the liberating feeling of no longer having to worry about making those monthly debt payments.

The Case for Investing

On the flip side, there’s a strong argument for investing extra funds rather than prioritizing debt payoff, especially if you have relatively low-interest debt. Over the long-term, the stock market has historically delivered average annual returns of around 10%. So by investing your extra money, you have the potential to grow your wealth at a much faster rate than you’d be able to by simply eliminating debt.

This is particularly relevant for younger investors who have a longer time horizon to benefit from the power of compounding returns. Even small, consistent investments can turn into sizable sums given enough time in the market.

For example, let’s say you have $500 per month to allocate. If you were to invest that $500 each month and earn an average annual return of 8%, after 30 years you’d have over $600,000. But if you were to use that $500 per month to pay down a 5% interest loan, you’d only save around $150,000 in interest over the life of the loan.

Of course, investing also carries more risk than debt payoff. The stock market can be volatile in the short-term, and there’s no guarantee of positive returns, especially in the near-term. But for long-term investors with a diversified portfolio, the historical data suggests investing is likely to outperform debt payoff over time.

Additionally, certain types of debt, like low-interest student loans or mortgages, can actually be beneficial to maintain if the interest rate is lower than what you could reasonably expect to earn through investing. This allows you to leverage low-cost debt to grow your wealth.

Comparing the Numbers: Debt Payoff vs. Investing

To give you a more tangible sense of how the numbers play out, let’s look at a couple of examples:

Scenario 1: High-Interest Debt Let’s say you have a credit card with a balance of $10,000 and an APR of 20%. If you were to put an extra $300 per month towards paying that down, you’d be debt-free in about 3 years and 4 months, and you’d have saved over $4,000 in interest.

Now let’s say instead of paying down that debt, you invested that $300 per month and earned an average annual return of 8%. After 3 years and 4 months, your investment account would be worth around $12,500.

In this scenario, paying down the high-interest debt is the clear winner, as you’d be saving a significant amount in interest payments.

Scenario 2: Lower-Interest Debt Now let’s look at a scenario with lower-interest debt, like a student loan with a 5% APR and a $20,000 balance. If you put an extra $300 per month towards that loan, you’d be debt-free in just under 6 years and save around $3,500 in interest.

However, if you invested that $300 per month at an 8% average annual return, after 6 years your investment account would be worth around $25,000.

In this case, the investment approach comes out ahead, as the potential investment returns outweigh the interest savings from the debt payoff.

Of course, these are just hypothetical examples. Your actual numbers will depend on your specific debts, interest rates, investment returns, and time horizons. But hopefully these illustrations give you a sense of how to think through the tradeoffs.

Other Factors to Consider

In addition to the pure numbers, there are a few other important factors to weigh when deciding between debt payoff and investing:

Your Risk Tolerance: As mentioned earlier, investing carries more short-term risk than debt payoff. If you have a lower risk tolerance or are closer to retirement, you may want to prioritize the guaranteed “return” of eliminating debt over the potential upside of investing.

Your Financial Goals: What are you trying to achieve – becoming debt-free, building long-term wealth, or something else? Aligning your strategy with your primary financial goals can help guide the decision.

Your Discipline: Paying off debt requires consistent, disciplined payments over time. Investing also requires discipline to stick to your plan, even through market downturns. Be honest with yourself about which approach you’re more likely to follow through on.

Tax Implications: Depending on your specific situation, there may be tax advantages or disadvantages to either debt payoff or investing. Consulting a tax professional can help you understand the implications.

Emergency Savings: It’s generally recommended to have 3-6 months’ worth of living expenses in an emergency fund before aggressively paying down debt or investing. This provides a financial buffer in case of unexpected events.

The Hybrid Approach

After considering all of these factors, you may find that the best approach is not an either/or decision, but rather a hybrid strategy that involves both debt payoff and investing.

For example, you could allocate a portion of your extra funds each month towards high-interest debt, while investing the remainder in a diversified portfolio. Or you could focus on building up your emergency savings first, then split any additional funds between debt payoff and investing.

The key is to find a balance that aligns with your specific financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance. It may take some trial and error to land on the right mix, but the important thing is to be intentional about how you’re allocating your money.

Conclusion

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the question of whether you should prioritize paying off debt or investing extra money. It depends on your unique circumstances and financial priorities.

The most important thing is to carefully evaluate the tradeoffs, crunch the numbers, and develop a strategy that makes the most sense for you. Don’t be afraid to seek guidance from a financial advisor if you need help navigating this decision.

Whichever path you choose, the important thing is to take action and make progress towards improving your overall financial well-being. Whether that means becoming debt-free or growing your long-term wealth, either approach can put you on a stronger financial footing.

So take a close look at your situation, weigh the pros and cons, and then make the decision that feels right for you. Your future self will thank you.

Ready to take control of your finances? Visit upgrade.com now to explore a range of financial products, including Personal Loans, Auto Refinance Loans, Home Improvement Loans, Personal Credit Lines, and Upgrade Card. Let Upgrade help you achieve your financial goals today!

FAQ: Paying Off Debt vs. Investing Extra Money

Q: Is it better to pay off debt or invest if I have both high-interest debt and extra cash?

A: When deciding between paying off high-interest debt and investing, it’s generally recommended to prioritize debt payoff first. High-interest debt, like credit card debt, can quickly accumulate and hinder your financial progress. By focusing on eliminating this costly debt, you can save on interest payments and improve your overall financial health before shifting your focus to investing.

Q: Should I pay off all my debt before starting to invest?

A: It’s not always necessary to pay off all your debt before starting to invest. If you have low-interest debt, like a mortgage or student loans, and the interest rates are lower than what you could earn through investing, it may make sense to simultaneously contribute to investments while making minimum payments on these debts. However, high-interest debt should typically be prioritized for payoff before investing.

Q: How do I determine the best approach for my financial situation – debt payoff or investing?

A: To determine the best approach for your financial situation, consider factors such as the interest rates on your debts, your risk tolerance, your financial goals, and your overall financial stability. Calculate the potential savings from paying off debt versus the potential returns from investing to see which option aligns best with your circumstances and objectives.

Q: What if I have a mix of low-interest and high-interest debt?

A: If you have a mix of low-interest and high-interest debt, a balanced approach may be appropriate. Prioritize paying off high-interest debt first to reduce the amount of interest you’re paying, while simultaneously making minimum payments on low-interest debt. Once high-interest debt is paid off, you can then allocate more funds towards investing or paying down remaining debts.

Q: Can I invest while still having debt?

A: Yes, you can invest while still having debt, especially if the interest rates on your debts are relatively low. It’s essential to strike a balance between debt payoff and investing based on your financial goals and risk tolerance. By carefully managing both aspects, you can work towards building wealth while also addressing your outstanding debts responsibly.

Share Your Expertise, Build Your Business. Tired of limitations?
Create & sell online courses with Teachable. Keep 100% control. Start your free!